M

Local Search Rankings

Top 5 Mortgage Lenders in Central Islip, NY

The 5 mortgage lenders Central Islip borrowers consistently turn to — ranked by the depth and consistency of verified reviews from people who've actually worked with them.

Central Islip, New York · Suffolk County · pop. 37,751

95

Lenders Analyzed

5.0

Median Rating

4

Median Reviews

94%

% Claimed

The top 5 mortgage lenders in Central Islip, NY

1

Nicholas Schmidtke

4.9(65 reviews)Claimed

Mortgage broker

Why they rank #1

  • 65 reviews built up over time
  • 64 of 65 reviews are five-star (98%)
  • Listing claimed and verified
  • Full operating hours posted
  • Categorized as "Mortgage broker"
+1516-967-8643www.rcgmortgage.com
M–F 8:30-20:00
2

Donny Schulze

5(44 reviews)Claimed

Mortgage lender

Why they rank #2

  • 44 of 44 reviews are five-star (100%)
  • Listing claimed and verified
  • Full operating hours posted
  • Categorized as "Mortgage lender"
M–F 0:00-24:00
3

Keara Mooney

4.9(41 reviews)Claimed

Mortgage broker

Why they rank #3

  • 39 of 41 reviews are five-star (95%)
  • Listing claimed and verified
  • Full operating hours posted
  • Categorized as "Mortgage broker"
+1516-967-8540kearamooney.com
mon 8:00-20:00, tue 9:00-19:00, wed 9:00-19:00, thu 8:00-19:00, fri 8:00-18:00
4

Kevin Ungar

5(35 reviews)Claimed

Mortgage broker

Why they rank #4

  • 35 of 35 reviews are five-star (100%)
  • Listing claimed and verified
  • 70 photos uploaded
  • Full operating hours posted
  • Categorized as "Mortgage broker"
+1516-376-8710
M–F 8:30-17:00
5

Dina Dal Mut

5(32 reviews)Claimed

Mortgage broker

Why they rank #5

  • 32 of 32 reviews are five-star (100%)
  • Listing claimed and verified
  • 11 photos on the listing
  • Full operating hours posted
  • Categorized as "Mortgage broker"
+1631-796-4350www.rcgmortgage.com
mon 8:00-18:00, tue 8:00-18:00, wed 8:00-17:00, thu 8:00-18:00, fri 8:00-19:00

How to pick the right mortgage lender in Central Islip

The five mortgage lenders above all rank highly — but they reach the top in different ways. Here's how to read the data so you can match the right one to your situation.

  • Look at review volume, not just rating. The median mortgage lender in Central Islip has just 4 reviews — the top-5 averages 43. A 5.0 across 200 borrowers means something very different from a 5.0 across 4. The deeper the review pool, the harder it is to fake.
  • A claimed local-search listing is table stakes. 94% of Central Islip mortgage lenders bother to claim and verify their profile, and all five above have done so. An unclaimed listing usually means the business pays less attention to where customers find them online — sometimes a sign of how they handle communication too.
  • Photos are a small but real signal of investment. The average Central Islip mortgage lender has 9 photos on their listing. It's not the most important factor, but a mortgage lender who posts nothing visual is one who treats their public presence as an afterthought.
  • Match hours to your schedule. 92% of Central Islip mortgage lenders post full weekday hours. If you work a 9–5 and can't take calls during the day, scan the hours block on each card above — some flag weekend or evening availability, which is rare and worth the shortlist if you need it.

Other mortgage lenders in Central Islip

6Prestige Home Buyers
4.9· 34 reviews
7Stress Free Homebuyer
4.8· 34 reviews
8Bruce Silva
5· 26 reviews
9Ralph Ranieri
5· 19 reviews
10Eric Buhler
5· 17 reviews
11Brian Maguire
5· 16 reviews
12Joseph P Ferraro
4.7· 14 reviews
13Virginia Donovan
5· 8 reviews
14Dana J. George
4.9· 8 reviews
15Ronald Contrelli
5· 6 reviews
See all 95

Frequently asked about mortgage lenders in Central Islip

Who is the top-ranked mortgage lender in Central Islip, NY?

Nicholas Schmidtke currently holds the #1 spot in Central Islip for local-search visibility, with 65 reviews at a 4.9-star rating. Rankings are based on publicly available business profile data.

How many mortgage lenders are there in Central Islip, NY?

We tracked 95 mortgage lenders with a business profile in Central Islip, NY. The list above shows the top 5 ranked by local-search visibility.

What's a typical review count for a mortgage lender in Central Islip?

The median mortgage lender in Central Islip has 4 verified reviews. The top-ranked mortgage lenders typically sit several multiples above the median — review depth is one of the strongest signals local-search ranking weighs.

Do most Central Islip mortgage lenders claim their local-search listing?

About 94% of Central Islip mortgage lenders have claimed and verified their business profile. Claimed listings rank higher and let the lender control hours, photos, and Q&A — it's the single highest-leverage local-SEO step.

How are these rankings calculated?

Rankings are based on publicly available local-search data — review count, star rating, claimed status, photo activity, and review-distribution patterns. We re-rank regularly so the top of this page reflects the current local-search picture in Central Islip.

Statewide rankings
Top loan officers across New York
View New York

Nearby cities

Want to rank higher?

See what the top 5 in Central Islip do that you don't.

We'll audit your business listing, compare you to the top-ranked lenders in Central Islip, and show you exactly what to fix.

Rankings based on publicly available local-search data. Updated regularly.